Thoreau’s Belief in Government

Thoreaus Resistance to Civil Government is the physique of his desire for a free thinking nation that knows right from victimize and is willing to fight for what they believe in. But charm these ideals are adjust and good in moderation, they can be made wrong if followed to the extreme. I believe that while Thoreau was a great writer with great ideas, a lot of what he believed was a little too over the top. Americans, by inalienable right, tolerate the freedom to speak their opinions without fear of persecution. It is this amendment that has led the rustic through some of its greatest movements and has supported its best causes.Henry Thoreau was very sore of the freedom of speech, and made this quite clear by his many essays regarding the government. However, as he says in Resistance, the power of speech is not enough. bingle must do something in order to get what they want. In Thoreaus case, this consisted of reenforcement alone in the woods, not stipendiary taxes and rot ting in lock for a night. While it is often said that actions speak louder than words, I believe that a well indite speech can do a lot more good than a halfcocked action.For, Thoreaus achievement did not fall out from spending a night in jail, but from using the consume symbolically in a published pass water. Had he not written about it, no one would have known, and the statement would not have been made. Thoreau seems to have thought himself above his fellow Americans in intelligence, despite his claims to the contrary. His seclusion from his neighbors so that he could meditate on his own, his constant use of words like ignorant to describe his countrymen, and his refusal to pay his taxes for a society that he has not joined all show of his arrogant nature.Thoreau tried to accomplish face by visiting his neighbors once in a while in order to appear sociable, and he claimed that he was okay with paying taxes for the basiss that he took part in. But if I had been Thoreaus n eighbor, I would have been offend by his visits, knowing that he comes provided to patronize and bombard me with his professional knowledge. I also feel that such a man of the people, as Thoreau claimed to be, should be more than willing to support a tax for an institution he freely chose not to be a part of if only to support his fellow man who does not feel the same way.Resistance is serious of Thoreaus ideals and beliefs, and while they may seem solid on the surface, they are support by the arrogant views of a man that believes his opinion is best. Just because Thoreaus ideas work for him, do not mean that they would work for all of America. And even though he spins his words in such a pretty and win over way, I personally can find better ways to imprint a difference than sitting, uselessly, behind bars.